Hyperpat\’s HyperDay

SF, science, and daily living

Venturing into the Big, Wide World

Posted by hyperpat on May 7, 2008

My son, as part of a school project for his class in government, had to attend a city council meeting last night. His comment about this three hour meeting: “I don’t speak politic”. He found much of the discussion totally opaque, and about as interesting as watching mud drying. This is not too surprising for a couple of reasons: local politics, even in a large city, most often deals with minuscule issues, normally of interest only to those directly affected, and discussions about same are almost necessarily couched in bureaucratese, a totally mind-numbing language seemingly designed expressly to obfuscate just what is being discussed and confuse any normal person. Heated interesting arguments and world-changing consequences are just not part of this picture.

Of more interest is the fact that the school course has such projects at all. And the city council is only one part of what my son has to do – he also is required to put some time in actually working for a political party office (of his choice – anywhere from Democrats to GreenPeace). And of course do a write up of his experiences and what he learned from them. These outings into the real world will at least provide him with a much better picture of what government is all about and how it really works than I got from school.

Back when I was his age (an incredibly long time ago), the classes I took in U. S. government and civics were pure lectures, and almost totally divorced from any current events or the practicalities of the political world. Now these classes gave me a good grounding in the Constitution and my civil rights and responsibilities, but they did not provide any type of picture of why or how I should get involved in politics. The high schools of my day pretty much left this up to the colleges and real-life experience after graduation, when suddenly the effect of a change in, say, zoning laws could have a real and very visible impact on your daily life, and made you realize that all these talking heads spouting esoteric mumble-mumble were important.

This is one change in modern education that I think is worthwhile. More practical, real-life things are very helpful in making the kids realize that what the teachers are trying to instill in them is useful – especially as far too many schools have discontinued the classes in shop, home economics, auto mechanics, and other such classes that used to provide at least a small taste of reality. Robert Heinlein, in Tunnel in the Sky, proposed a much harsher taste of reality, a school course in survival, where the final exam was to be dropped into some unknown land and forced to really survive for some time period. It’s doubtful this would ever become a reality, with its real risk of fatalities, and parents simply wouldn’t be willing to take that risk. Though in today’s world, their kids sometimes enlist in the military very shortly after graduation and are really placed in harm’s way – but most people wouldn’t be able to see the equivalency of these risks.

The real world is neither safe nor comfortable, and young people do need to learn how to navigate its reefs and shoals. Schools that don’t provide at least a small taste of what the big, wide world is all about are doing their students no favors.


2 Responses to “Venturing into the Big, Wide World”

  1. Peter said

    I have often thought that a required ‘Home Accounting’ – or some such class should be taught. This class would explain how to balance a checkbook, how credit cards work, mortgages, etc. In general, a class to make kids more money savvy.

  2. hyperpat said

    I agree with that idea – it seems so many kids simply have no idea of how to manage money, have no idea of what taxes are or how they impact their paycheck, don’t know what a budget is, let alone how to set one up and stay on it, etc, etc. My son’s economics class did at least try to cover some of this, along with having them do some dabbling in the stock market (there are several sites that allow you do this as a game, but with real stock prices). When I did my income taxes this year, my son was actually interested enough to sit down with me and see how I filled them out, at least enough so he now knows how to do a 1040A – I figured he can get into all the other nasty details of Schedules A, B, D, and the Alternative Minimum Tax when he has a need for it, which will probably be many years down the road.

    And it certainly wouldn’t hurt these kid’s to realize just how useful math is if they would relate the classroom study of exponents to the compound interest on credit cards and the amortization schedules of mortgages! Might make them a little more leery of those shiny bits of plastic and the buy now, pay later come-ons.

    Yep, Home Accounting sounds like just the thing, and it should be a mandatory class.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: